Start here
Choose a situation to see how you might open the conversation, what facts to have on hand, and how to ask for a decision. The examples are written for agents, with language buyers and sellers can use to prepare for their own conversations.
Before you respond
What needs an answer on this call? If the seller is reacting to a low offer, decide whether the goal is to counter today or gather information first. Keep the opening focused on that one decision.
Bring one fact the other person can evaluate, such as the proposed closing date, a documented inspection finding, or a comparable sale. If you’re missing a key fact, make getting it the next step.
Ask your client which term is firm and which they’re open to discussing. If you have room to explore timing or another term, confirm the limits before you bring it up with the other side.
Price and expectations
01 / Seller conversation
Use this when the first number feels disappointing and the seller wants to end the conversation immediately. Give the seller time to react, then put the offer in the context of the home’s recent activity and the terms that affect their move.
Try saying
“I can see why that number feels low. Before we decide how to respond, let’s look at the recent sales, what buyers have said at showings, and what this buyer is offering on timing. If those terms help you, what price would make a counter worth considering?”
What to bring into the conversation. Bring a short list of comparable sales and describe where the properties differ. If you’re reviewing a home in Round Rock, the Round Rock market report can provide broader context. Use property-specific comparisons to discuss the offer itself.
How to close the conversation. Ask the seller to choose between a specific counter, a request for clarification, or declining the offer. Confirm the response before you relay it.
02 / Pricing conversation
A seller may need time to adjust expectations, especially when the asking price reflects what they planned to put toward their next home. Separate the seller’s financial goal from the evidence buyers are responding to.
Try saying
“We can give the current price more time. Let’s pick a date to check back and agree on what we’ll review. If showings stay quiet or buyers raise the same concern again, would you be open to comparing a price change with keeping the home listed as it is?”
What to bring into the conversation. Agree on the evidence you’ll bring to the next meeting. For example, compare showing activity, recurring feedback, and changes to competing listings. The team’s home pricing guidance is a starting point for that discussion.
How to close the conversation. Set the review date while you’re together. Ask what trade-off the seller would be comfortable making between more time on the market and a change in price.
Clarity and scope
03 / Client conversation
A fee question can mean the client is comparing proposals, is unsure what is included, or needs to understand what they will pay. Start by finding out which question they want answered.
Try saying
“I’m happy to walk through the proposed fee. Would it help to compare what’s included, or are you mainly trying to understand your total cost? We can go through the services, how the fee would work, and any questions you’d like answered before you decide.”
What to bring into the conversation. Describe what you would actually do during the transaction. For example, explain how you would organize competing offers, track agreed next steps, or help the client evaluate a repair request. If they are comparing proposals, lay out the differences in scope and cost in plain language.
How to close the conversation. Ask the client what support matters most to them. Recap the scope and fee discussed, and give them time to review the written proposal before deciding.
04 / Inspection conversation
An inspection report can make every item feel urgent. Ask which finding changes the buyer’s decision and which items could be handled later. A focused conversation gives the seller something specific to evaluate.
Try saying
“The electrical panel is the item the buyers want to understand before deciding how to proceed. Would your seller be open to reviewing an electrician’s assessment and estimate? Once we have that, we can discuss which option each side would consider.”
What to bring into the conversation. Use the report and these questions to ask a home inspector to identify what still needs a specialist’s opinion. If the parties want to compare options, use the same scope of work so everyone is discussing the same issue.
How to close the conversation. Confirm who will obtain the assessment and when the parties expect to hear back. Keep the discussion tied to the timing of the transaction and confirm any agreed changes through the appropriate process.
Trade-offs and timing
05 / Offer comparison
A strong price can come with terms that complicate the seller’s move. Compare the offers in the same order so the seller can see what each one asks them to give up.
Try saying
“This offer has the highest price, and the proposed closing date is two weeks earlier than you planned. If the buyer can move that date, would this be your preferred offer? If the date is firm, let’s compare the extra proceeds with what you would need to spend or rearrange to move sooner.”
What to bring into the conversation. Show the seller the proposed price, expected costs, and timing side by side. Ask which detail would change their choice. Someone selling a Central Texas home while coordinating another move might value a later closing enough to choose a different offer.
How to close the conversation. Confirm which term you can ask to change and which alternative the seller prefers if the buyer cannot move the date.
06 / Agent-to-agent conversation
When the conversation has narrowed to one number, ask about a term that can still move. Choose something your client has already authorized you to explore, such as timing, and ask a question the other agent can take back to their client.
Try saying
“I hear that your client is firm on price. My client may have some flexibility on the closing date. Is timing something your client would consider changing, and would it help enough for them to revisit the rest of the offer?”
What to bring into the conversation. Before you make the call, clarify what your client can offer, what they would need in return, and when they want an answer. If the other side has no room to move on the term you raised, ask whether they see another issue worth discussing.
How to close the conversation. End with a specific follow-up. Agree who will check with their client, when you’ll reconnect, and what point you’re both taking back for a decision.
Worked example · Illustrative scenario
A Round Rock seller is willing to consider a lower offer if it gives them enough time to move. The buyer wants an earlier closing and also has a concern about a repair. Both sides have been talking about price, but they’re using the same number to solve different problems.
After a call with several moving pieces, a short written recap gives everyone a chance to correct a misunderstanding. Separate what each side is willing to explore from what they’ve agreed to. Include the person responsible for the next step and a time for the next update.
Sample follow-up. “Thanks for talking this through. I’ll check whether my seller can work with the proposed closing date. You’re going to confirm which repair the buyer wants evaluated first. Let’s reconnect tomorrow at 11 a.m. Please let me know if I missed anything.”
Quick answers
Yes. Use the questions to clarify what you want from the conversation, then discuss with your agent who should relay the response. If you’re considering a counter, write down the terms you’d accept and the ones you still want to discuss.
Try, “I want to review the offer with my client and give you a clear answer. I can update you by 3 p.m. Is there a response deadline I should confirm before we do that?” Agree on a time you can meet and follow through, even if your update is that you’re still waiting for information.
Summarize the term in plain language, confirm who will prepare the next written step, and check that both sides understood the same thing. If there are several moving pieces, recap each one separately so neither side has to reconstruct the conversation from memory.
Keep practicing
Pick a scenario and ask a teammate to play the other side. After the first run, repeat it with a new constraint, such as a shorter closing window or a seller who needs more time to decide. Practice asking one clear question at a time.
For more situations to rehearse, explore the Real Estate Negotiation Resource Center and the companion book, Mastering Real Estate Negotiation.
Have a Central Texas offer in hand or a counter you’re weighing? Bring the terms you’re looking at and the questions you still have. The Robert J. Fischer Team can help you talk through the options before you respond.
Talk to the RJF Team